Talk:Ubantu:Contents - Revision history

Greg 1 at 16:52, 1 March 2007

2007-03-01T16:52:52Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:52, 1 March 2007
Line 3:		Line 3:
	I did find it a bit confusing to work out what was going on, though. It would help if the premise is stated very clearly up front on the main page itself. It was only when I went to the "Major Projects" index of RPGnet Wicki that I learned that the game is set on Yrth. A historical timeline stating exactly what happened when, so that I can see the relationship between real world history and the history of this new world, would be very helpful.		I did find it a bit confusing to work out what was going on, though. It would help if the premise is stated very clearly up front on the main page itself. It was only when I went to the "Major Projects" index of RPGnet Wicki that I learned that the game is set on Yrth. A historical timeline stating exactly what happened when, so that I can see the relationship between real world history and the history of this new world, would be very helpful.

	Also, it isn't always clear when you are talking about Bantu mythology and when you are talking about the way things really are in the setting. For instance, at the start of the section about Wakonyingo, when they are physically described, it says that they have tails - but at the end, it says that on Yrth they don't have tails.		Also, it isn't always clear when you are talking about Bantu mythology and when you are talking about the way things really are in the setting. For instance, at the start of the section about Wakonyingo, when they are physically described, it says that they have tails - but at the end, it says that on Yrth they don't have tails (and are Elves!).

Greg 1 at 16:47, 1 March 2007

2007-03-01T16:47:42Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:47, 1 March 2007
Line 1:		Line 1:
			This looks like a very interesting setting indeed. I love the fact that it is based on an historical culture that has been sadly overlooked in RPGs.

	~~This looks like~~ a very ~~interesting setting indeed~~. I ~~love~~ the ~~fact~~ that it is ~~based~~ on an historical ~~culture~~ that ~~has been sadly overlooked in RPGs~~.		I did find it a bit confusing to work out what was going on, though. It would help if the premise is stated very clearly up front on the main page itself. It was only when I went to the "Major Projects" index of RPGnet Wicki that I learned that the game is set on Yrth. A historical timeline stating exactly what happened when, so that I can see the relationship between real world history and the history of this new world, would be very helpful.

	~~I did find~~ it ~~a bit confusing to work out what was going on, though. It would help if~~ the ~~premise is stated very clearly up front~~. ~~Frankly~~, ~~I'm not even sure if~~ the ~~game is set on Yrth or not! A historical timeline stating exactly what happened~~ when, so that ~~I can see~~ the ~~relationship between real world history and the history of this new world~~, ~~would be very helpful~~.		Also, it isn't always clear when you are talking about Bantu mythology and when you are talking about the way things really are in the setting. For instance, at the start of the section about Wakonyingo, when they are physically described, it says that they have tails - but at the end, it says that on Yrth they don't have tails.

Greg 1 at 16:43, 1 March 2007

2007-03-01T16:43:32Z

New page

This looks like a very interesting setting indeed. I love the fact that it is based on an historical culture that has been sadly overlooked in RPGs.

I did find it a bit confusing to work out what was going on, though. It would help if the premise is stated very clearly up front. Frankly, I'm not even sure if the game is set on Yrth or not! A historical timeline stating exactly what happened when, so that I can see the relationship between real world history and the history of this new world, would be very helpful.