The Stars Are Right: The Irish Rose: Rhyner Interview

Unsurprisingly he takes you straight back to the building you just left. The boy knocks, then opens the door and holds it for you.

Things are not too different from when you were here before. The dishware has been cleared away, and another carafe of water and new glasses sit in their place. The bottle of brandy is still there, as well as the scattering of papers. The fire has burnt down a bit, and the lamps throw pools of light across the table, leaving the rest of the room in dim shadows. Hannelore Rhyner looks up when you enter, setting aside a pen and paper. Regarding you frankly from where she sits.

"Mr. Lovejoy. Thank you for coming. I wasn't sure you'd accept." She makes a gesture towards the nearby chairs around the table. "Please, be as comfortable as you can." Her voice is warm without being intimate.

Lovejoy tips his hat, not without irony, and slouches into a chair. He makes a little ceremony of taking out his notebook, turning to a fresh page, licking his pen. "So," he says. "You wanted to see me?"

A fleeting expression of bemusement crosses her face, as she folds her hands on the table top. "Mr. Lovejoy, I prefer honesty over politeness, even as I recognize there is a proper place and time for both. I'm going to make some presumptions, and I hope you will correct me any place that I get things wrong. You seem to have little or no personal stake in what happens to us as a whole. I suspect that if you never came back to the Seelie Court - it would be of little consequence to you. As a newspaper man, there must be -- as they say -- 'bigger fish to fry', outside in the Shallow World. Corruption, greed, scandal, wrong doing to redress . . . yet . . ."

She pauses, and the brief smile is disarming. "I find you consistently mixed up with us. Risking your life in some cases to be of value to people whom you have little in common . . . and I suspect . . . probably don't even like much. Doctor Parkhurst sets great store by your integrity. I can understand, and certainly appreciate a man who does not compromise his integrity. What I have a more difficult time understanding is why." She tilts her head just a bit to regard you with open appraisal. "Mr. Lovejoy, why are you bothering at all about us?"

He spreads his hands. "You're not wrong. Most of what I've seen here paints all of you as freaks, crazies, outcasts and monsters. You hold yourself above and beyond people while relying on them for survival in ways that are ... parasitic isn't a kind word." (You see a moment of indignation at this. She starts to say something - but then doesn't.) "Far as I can tell you're a danger to yourselves and others -- but that's okay. That's what I make my living on. I don't like you, but that doesn't mean I can't sympathize with you. And then I'm a journalist. Maybe not a good one, and certainly not a well-paid one, but I try. And partly that means being willing to look, and listen, and delay judgment."

He leans forward. "And you're people. You may not think you're human -- or that you're some different kind of human, I don't know -- but humanity's not a badge you turn in just because you get sick or are born different or on anyone's say so. That makes you part of my crowd, part of everyone's crowd. You -- some of you -- live in my city. You're friends or enemies with some of my friends or enemies. When you pull out your knives and your hoodoo and your claws and go to war with whoever it is, some of that plays out in my city, or my country, or my world. Should I look away from that just because I don't like you?"

"I don't like these Jewish punks and their friends that have been running Detroit into the ground since before Volstead got his bright idea, but should I look away from them, too? Should I not talk to them, listen to them, write about them, just because I don't like 'em and they don't like me? You talk about bigger fish to fry, and maybe they're bigger than you are, or maybe not, but I tell you I'm not the only one covering that particular beat, and I seem to be the only one covering this one."

"You say I've put my neck out for you, and I guess that's maybe true, but it ain't anything I wouldn't do for anyone else. Axler, maybe he'll drop me in the lake and good riddance to me, but if Capone made off with his wife and I knew about it I'd pass the word along. He asks me to come watch the fireworks I'd say sure. It'd wind up in the papers and I'd tell the Hart's boys about it before anything happened, but I'd go. I don't see as how you folks are much different." He leans back. "'Course, I don't know as you're much better, either, but I guess that what I'm here looking to find out."

During the whole of your speech, you feel her gaze. The more you speak, the more intense her attention focuses on you. She leans forward, watching every nuance of your body language, weighing the words as if their content holds some deeper meaning. It is quite flattering . . . and perhaps just a bit unnerving. Silence falls between the two of you for a few moments. She relaxes just a bit, with a small nod.

"Fair enough." the words are soft, yet you hear the strength beneath them. "Your candor is much the more valued for it's lack of varnish . That you don't sugar coat any of it . . . is refreshing." flicker of a smile, quickly gone. "Much of your assessment is correct. The Seelie are insulated here, caught up in their own small circles of social ritual. That people . . . like you . . . " a gesture towards you pointedly, "brand them 'freaks and monsters' is one of the compelling reasons that this place was constructed. A haven, to live in peace and raise their Children."

A sigh, as she looks for exactly the right words. "The many faults that you point out are partially due to the Condition, partially due to past history and traditions . . . and partially due to simple human failings. These are not excuses, they are just facts, just the way things are. Which I assure you - are much better now than ever before. But of course you have no way to judge - having never been exposed to what they were before . . ." She trails off into silence, looking away from you for the first time, to some place that seems to be in the distant past. A blink or two, before she pulls her thoughts back to the here and now.

"I'm not offended that you don't like the Seelie. And I'm not offended that you apparently don't like me either. I think that people can still find common cause, even if their personalities are in conflict. Moreover, I'm not entirely sure that the Seelie need to prove themselves to you. Though your good opinion certainly has value to me. Given that the conflict we face is larger and more sweeping than all of our small concerns put together. There will be opportunity enough then for evidence that the Seelie have not 'turned in their badge'." The turn of phrase evidently appeals to her.

"I appreciate all that you've done, and all that you've risked in helping them. Even if it is something you'd do for anyone, the Seelie have few enough people willing to get involved with their concerns. I hope you find whatever you need to give you a better opinion of them. A certain sense of my own pride is rather tied up in that, I fear." She looks down at her hands briefly, somewhat embarrassed at the confession. Then, eyes up to you again. "And of course, I'd offer to answer any questions you'd like to ask. But then, all of my answers would be suspect on some level - would they not?" You can tell she is perhaps teasing you just a bit.

"Mr. Lovejoy, despite all of the differences between us, there are some things that still remain fundamentally the same. Respect. Truthfulness. Honesty. Someday, I'd like to add friendship to that list . . . but I know that will be a long time in coming - if ever."

Lovejoy snorts. "Don't get me wrong. I don't think you're monsters on account of anything you are, but what you do. Is Dr. Parkhurst less of a monster than Abe Axler? More? Than Capone? Than Chancellor Hitler? Is Farbeque? Vishnevsky?" He turns his hands over noncomitally. "As for trusting you, well, I don't expect you to be any more honest than any other mayor, queen or potentate. You've got more people than just yourself to worry about, and that sort of responsibility breeds its own standards of honesty. You tell me your story and we'll see where it fits with everyone else's." Lovejoy smiles, broadly and toothily. "Pile up enough lies from enough different people and you start to see the shape of things underneath." He spins his pen around his fingers and raises his eyebrows. "So. Who killed Macklin?"