Editing User talk:Andrensath/Exalted/Custom/Charms
Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.
The edit can be undone.
Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
| Latest revision | Your text | ||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | + | =Rhythm-Breaking Attack= | |
| − | |||
*Since it can't be used in a flurry, why not make it a Simple Charm? Also note that a perfect parry will still negate this Charm even if it is explicitly mentioned in the Charm text, since that is how they work. Finally there should be a keyword, probably Crippling, to the effect. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | *Since it can't be used in a flurry, why not make it a Simple Charm? Also note that a perfect parry will still negate this Charm even if it is explicitly mentioned in the Charm text, since that is how they work. Finally there should be a keyword, probably Crippling, to the effect. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ||
**Hmmm. It doesn't feel Simple to me, but I could see it being an attack of it's own. I'm uncomfortable with allowing perfect parries to negate it, as the charm usage has to be declared upfront, and I think people will just go 'RBB? I perfect parry', rendering the charm pointless to take, let alone use. I can definitely see it being Crippling, and will probably make that change, though. --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | **Hmmm. It doesn't feel Simple to me, but I could see it being an attack of it's own. I'm uncomfortable with allowing perfect parries to negate it, as the charm usage has to be declared upfront, and I think people will just go 'RBB? I perfect parry', rendering the charm pointless to take, let alone use. I can definitely see it being Crippling, and will probably make that change, though. --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | ||
***So it joins the club of every other supplemental Charm in the book? Trying to get around perfect defenses is bad design IMO. And note that a perfect defense will still be a win for the MArtist, mote economy wise. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ***So it joins the club of every other supplemental Charm in the book? Trying to get around perfect defenses is bad design IMO. And note that a perfect defense will still be a win for the MArtist, mote economy wise. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ||
****It's not getting around perfect defenses, though. It's 'if you parry, this happens'. I can see where you're coming from on the mote economy thing, but I'd still note that the MArtist has to actually be capable of hitting first. --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | ****It's not getting around perfect defenses, though. It's 'if you parry, this happens'. I can see where you're coming from on the mote economy thing, but I'd still note that the MArtist has to actually be capable of hitting first. --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | ||
| − | + | =Immense Weapon Deflection= | |
*Interesting idea, better priced at 6m, I think. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | *Interesting idea, better priced at 6m, I think. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ||
**I think that might weaken it too much. Maybe 5m? --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | **I think that might weaken it too much. Maybe 5m? --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | ||
***I stand by my suggestion. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ***I stand by my suggestion. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ||
****In that case, sorry, but Sunrunner is fine with it as-is. --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | ****In that case, sorry, but Sunrunner is fine with it as-is. --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | ||
| − | + | =Glorious Blade Form= | |
*(Ess+MA)/2 is too much. For comparison, this is the equivalent in power to two HFoE Solar Melee Charms. Make it (Ess/2) and maybe add some small additional benefit for flavor. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | *(Ess+MA)/2 is too much. For comparison, this is the equivalent in power to two HFoE Solar Melee Charms. Make it (Ess/2) and maybe add some small additional benefit for flavor. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ||
**Which Charms? --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | **Which Charms? --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | ||
***Whirling Dervish Method (HFoE, p. 6). --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ***Whirling Dervish Method (HFoE, p. 6). --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ||
****Hmmm. Maybe leave it at (Ess+MA)/2 but raise it to 7 or 8m? --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | ****Hmmm. Maybe leave it at (Ess+MA)/2 but raise it to 7 or 8m? --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | ||
| − | + | ||
| + | =Furious Sword Mudra= | ||
*This should cost 2m, I think. Note that the Even Blade style Charm that does something similar IIRC costs 4m. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | *This should cost 2m, I think. Note that the Even Blade style Charm that does something similar IIRC costs 4m. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ||
**Is that '2m per attack', or flat 2m? --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | **Is that '2m per attack', or flat 2m? --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | ||
***I meant 2m per attack. I should look up that other Charm for comparison, though. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ***I meant 2m per attack. I should look up that other Charm for comparison, though. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ||
| − | + | =Blade Like Lightning Kata= | |
*No. Just no. This Charm should either have a per attack cost (3m/attack, maximum of rate) or give a flat number of attacks (for example (MA rating) attacks for, say, 8m, 1wp. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | *No. Just no. This Charm should either have a per attack cost (3m/attack, maximum of rate) or give a flat number of attacks (for example (MA rating) attacks for, say, 8m, 1wp. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ||
**A per attack cost with cap of (Rate) would make it far worse than the Solar Melee equivalents, though, which would render this Charm pointless for its IC developer. Maybe add a clause forbidding it from being used with infinite rate weapons? --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | **A per attack cost with cap of (Rate) would make it far worse than the Solar Melee equivalents, though, which would render this Charm pointless for its IC developer. Maybe add a clause forbidding it from being used with infinite rate weapons? --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] | ||
***Compare the Charm you're proposing to the extra-action Charms in other CMA styles. I feel my proposed version is much more in line with the examples they give. And yes, CMA ''are'' less powerful than Solar Charms, that's a simple fact. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ***Compare the Charm you're proposing to the extra-action Charms in other CMA styles. I feel my proposed version is much more in line with the examples they give. And yes, CMA ''are'' less powerful than Solar Charms, that's a simple fact. --[[User:Dakkareth|Dakkareth]] | ||
| − | ****'Less powerful'! | + | ****'Less powerful'!='Why are you taking this when you have access to Solar Melee', though. --[[User:Andrensath|Andrensath]] |
